Why did this happen to me? #3 - When Friends Aren’t Helpful

Description

Dr. Kurt Bjorklund explores Job 15-21, revealing that while friends may offer "miserable comfort" through judgment or "better comfort" through presence, the best comfort comes from knowing our living Redeemer who will stand on the earth. When suffering strikes, your ultimate hope isn't found in circumstances or even good friends, but in Jesus Christ who has bought back your life from sin and will one day restore all that's broken.

 

Summary and Application

When hardship strikes—whether it's job loss, broken relationships, or health crises—one of our most natural questions is: "Where is God?" The Book of Job directly addresses this timeless struggle, offering wisdom that goes far beyond easy answers.

In his sermon on Job 15-21, Kurt explores three levels of comfort available to us in suffering: miserable comfort, better comfort, and the best comfort. Understanding these distinctions can transform how we both receive and offer support during life's darkest seasons.

Miserable Comfort: When Truth Becomes Toxic

Job's friends believed they had God figured out. Their theology was simple: righteous people prosper, wicked people suffer. Therefore, if Job was suffering, he must have sinned. As Job laments in Job 16:2, "I have heard many things like these. You are miserable comforters, all of you."

What made their comfort so miserable wasn't that everything they said was false. Kurt points out that "false teaching, false doctrine, doesn't parade itself as false doctrine that's always completely wrong and obvious, or it wouldn't be tempting to anybody." The friends' error was taking partial truths and applying them rigidly and universally, without listening to Job's actual situation.

This creates what Kurt calls "double pain"—the pain of the suffering itself plus the pain of being told you deserve it. He illustrates this with contemporary examples: the couple struggling with infertility being told it's because of past sins, or parents whose children have strayed being judged by parents whose children seem to follow God well.

The problem intensifies when we internalize this miserable comfort, telling ourselves that our emotions are invalid or that expressing struggle means we lack faith. But Job's raw honesty throughout 42 chapters tells us otherwise. Kurt emphasizes: "If you find yourself in a place where you're telling yourself that you shouldn't feel a certain way or you shouldn't express your emotions, that I don't believe that that's of God."

Better Comfort: The Ministry of Presence

Before Job's friends opened their mouths, they did something powerful: they sat with him in silence for seven days. This, Kurt suggests, was "probably their best reaction in the moment."

Job himself reveals what he needs most in Job 21:2: "Listen carefully to my words. Let this be the consolation you give me." Better comfort involves two biblical principles: "Rejoice with those who rejoice, and mourn with those who mourn" (Romans 12:15), and the wisdom to "listen to advice" (Proverbs 12:15).

Kurt shares a compelling story about comedian Gary Gulman, who struggled with severe depression as a young adult. A friend invited him to watch all 82 Boston Celtics games that season. "There were nights, especially at the beginning, that we hardly spoke a word," Kurt recounts. Yet this friend's consistent presence—82 nights of simply being there—was "instrumental in me coming back from my depression."

This illustrates that better comfort isn't about having the right words or theological explanations. It's about showing up, sitting with people in their pain, celebrating their victories, and sometimes offering appropriate challenge when they're ready to receive it.

The Best Comfort: A Living Redeemer

Yet even the best human comfort has limits. Proverbs 14:10 reminds us: "Each heart knows its own bitterness, and no one else can share its joy." No friend, no matter how devoted, can fully enter into our experience.

This reality points us to something—Someone—greater. In the middle of his anguish, Job makes one of Scripture's most profound declarations: "I know that my Redeemer lives, and that in the end he will stand on the earth" (Job 19:25).

Kurt explains that redemption isn't just about God's love—it's about God's sacrificial action to buy us back from bondage we cannot escape ourselves. "Redemption means that you are bound to something that you have no control over, no hope from. And somebody comes along and does something that you couldn't do to buy you out of it."

When we grasp that Jesus has redeemed us from sin's ultimate penalty, we can trust Him to redeem all our present sufferings too. The best comfort isn't demanding better treatment from friends or even fixing our circumstances—it's knowing our identity is secure in Christ regardless of what we lose or gain in this life.

As Kurt puts it: "If God has redeemed me from sin and the ultimate punishment, then I can trust, as Job says here, that my Redeemer lives and I will see him stand on the earth or in my grave, that the end of the story is not now."

Questions for Reflection

  1. When you face difficulty, do you tend toward "miserable comfort"—rigidly applying spiritual principles or blaming yourself? How might God be inviting you to express your honest emotions to Him, as Job did?

  2. Who in your life might need "better comfort" right now—someone who needs your presence more than your advice? What practical step could you take this week to simply sit with them in their struggle?

Dr. Kurt Bjorklund

Kurt is the Senior Pastor at Orchard Hill Church and has served in that role since 2005. Under his leadership, the church has grown substantially, developed the Wexford campus through two significant expansions, and launched two new campuses. Orchard Hill has continued to serve the under-served throughout the community.

Kurt’s teaching can be heard weekdays on the local Christian radio and his messages are broadcast on two different television stations in Pittsburgh. Kurt is a sought-after speaker, speaking at several Christian colleges and camps. He has published a book with Moody Press called, Prayers For Today.

Before Orchard Hill, Kurt led a church in Michigan through a decade of substantial growth. He worked in student ministry in Chicago as well as served as the Director of Outreach/Missions for Trinity International University. Kurt graduated from Wheaton College (BA), Trinity Divinity School (M. Div), and Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary (D. Min).

Kurt and his wife, Faith, have four sons.

https://twitter.com/KurtBjorklund1
Previous
Previous

Getting Started with Discipleship

Next
Next

Take His Hand: How Jesus Reaches Out to Change Lives